Back to Blog
Buying Guide

What Is the Best Meal Replacement Shake in the UK for Weight Loss? 2026 Prices Checked

The best meal replacement shakes in the UK compared on price per meal, protein, calories, fibre and sugar, with the cheapest shakes that still meet the UK rules, vegan picks, breakfast and shift-work options, and what the trials say about keeping the weight off.

KE

Kevin, founder of WheyWise

20 May 2026Updated 20 October 202613 min read

Quick answer

If you're cutting calories, buy Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM. One 60g serving gives 25g of protein in 216 kcal with 24 added vitamins and minerals, and it costs £1.20 a meal in the 4kg bag at £79.49 on Protein Works' OnTap subscription price. That puts it inside the 200 to 250 kcal band GB rules set for weight-control meal replacements, which a 400 kcal Huel meal sits well above, and it undercuts Huel Powder on Huel's own subscription, £1.59 a meal. If money is the tightest constraint, Diet Meal 360 BLACK is 98p a meal bought one-off, with less protein per serving.

The best meal replacement shake in the UK for weight loss is Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM, which gives 25g of protein in 216 kcal per 60g serving for £1.20 a meal in the 4kg bag on Protein Works' OnTap subscription price. It is the most complete formula in the Diet Meal 360 range, with 24 added vitamins and minerals. Other shakes win narrower jobs: Diet Meal 360 BLACK is the cheapest per meal, Huel Black Edition has the most protein, and Bulk 1 Complete Food Shake is a full vegan meal with the most fibre.

How we priced it: Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM and GOLD are quoted at Protein Works' OnTap subscription price, which is about 15% below the one-off price, because that is the price Protein Works publishes in its own product feed and we couldn't re-read the one-off price on its website. Every other price is a one-off price without a discount code, checked between 14 and 20 October 2026, and every nutrition figure was read from the label on the brand's own website, with the flavour named.

A bag of Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM next to a bag of Huel nutritionally complete protein, with a chocolate shake, two scoops of powder and a Huel shaker on a kitchen counter
Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM and a Huel shake. Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM gives 25g of protein in 216 kcal.

What is the best meal replacement shake in the UK for weight loss?

For a calorie-controlled diet, Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM is the one to buy: 25g of protein in 216 kcal for £1.20 a meal on OnTap. That is 46% of its energy from protein, inside the 25% to 50% that GB rules set for weight-control meal replacements, alongside 5.0g of fibre and 1.1g of sugar per serving on the Chocolate Silk label. If you want a full 400 kcal meal instead of a lighter diet meal, Huel Black Edition and Bulk 1 Complete Food Shake are the two to compare.

#1 Best meal replacement for weight loss

Pros

  • 25g of protein in 216 kcal per 60g serving, with 5.0g of fibre and 1.1g of sugar (Chocolate Silk label)
  • £1.20 a meal and £1.20 per 25g of protein in the 4kg bag at £79.49 on OnTap
  • 24 added vitamins and minerals, each at 30% or more of the NRV per serving
  • Sold in Speculoos Biscuit Heaven, which our founder scored 8.5 out of 10 in the GOLD version

Cons

  • A light 216 kcal meal, not a full 400 kcal replacement like Huel Powder
  • 5.0g of fibre per serving, against 8.0g in a Huel Powder meal
  • £1.20 is the subscription price; a one-off bag costs about 15% more
Buy Diet Meal 360 Platinum →Price at Protein Works
Exclusive WheyWise Code
Get 12% off your order
View on Amazon ↗
or compare all UK prices →
●Nutrition per scoop · 24.6g protein in 60g▼

Protein makes up 41%

of this 60g scoop · 209 kcal total

24.6g
19.2g
12.4g
Protein24.6g
Carbs19.2g
Fat3.8g
Other12.4g

Pros

  • 40g of protein in 400 kcal per 90g meal, with 8.4g of fibre and 1.6g of sugar (Matcha Latte label)
  • £1.25 per 25g of protein bought one-off, or £1.12 on a Huel subscription
  • Huel says it is 100% vegan, with 26 vitamins and minerals

Cons

  • £1.99 a meal bought one-off (£33.90 for 17 meals), the dearest per meal in this guide
  • A full 400 kcal meal, well above the 200 to 250 kcal diet-meal band
Buy Black Edition 100% Nutritionally Complete Meal →See the price on Amazon
●Nutrition per scoop · 39.6g protein in 90g▼

Protein makes up 44%

of this 90g scoop · 158 kcal total

39.6g
50.4g
Protein39.6g
Carbs0g
Fat0g
Other50.4g

Full vegan meal, most fibre

Pros

  • 400 kcal, 30g of protein, 9.6g of fibre and 2.3g of sugar per 100g meal, on bulk.com
  • £1.67 a meal and £1.39 per 25g of protein in the 3kg bag at £49.99
  • Vegan, with an added vitamin and mineral blend

Cons

  • A full 400 kcal meal, not a light diet shake
  • The 1.4kg bag works out at £1.93 a meal, so the saving needs the 3kg bag
or compare all UK prices →
●Nutrition per scoop · 30g protein in 100g▼

Protein makes up 30%

of this 100g scoop · 376 kcal total

30g
37g
21g
Protein30g
Carbs37g
Fat12g
Other21g

Which meal replacement shakes cost under £1.50 a meal?

Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM is the best shake under £1.50 a meal, at £1.20 on OnTap. Five others come in under £1.50 too: Diet Meal 360 BLACK at 98p bought one-off, Diet Meal 360 GOLD at £1.04 on OnTap, Myprotein Protein Meal Replacement Blend at £1.23, Protein Works Complete Meal 360 Gold at £1.37 and PER4M Meal Replacement at £1.43 on Amazon UK. Every shake in this guide costs under £2 a meal, with Huel Black Edition the dearest at £1.99 one-off. We also show cost per 25g of protein, the measure WheyWise uses for every powder, because a cheap meal with little protein is not a bargain.

ShakePackPricePer mealPer 25g of protein
Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM4kg, 66 meals£79.49 (OnTap)£1.20£1.20
Protein Works Diet Meal 360 GOLD4kg, 57 meals£59.49 (OnTap)£1.04£1.30
Protein Works Diet Meal 360 BLACK4kg, 61 meals£59.9998p£1.54
Myprotein Protein Meal Replacement Blend1.53kg, 30 meals£36.99£1.23£1.71
Protein Works Complete Meal 360 Gold4kg, 40 meals£54.99£1.37£1.15
PER4M Meal Replacement1.8kg, 30 meals£42.92 (Amazon UK)£1.43£1.43
Protein Works Vegan Complete Meal 360 Gold4kg, 40 meals£64.49£1.61n/a
Bulk 1 Complete Food Shake3kg, 30 meals£49.99£1.67£1.39
Huel Powder17 meals£30.00£1.76£1.47
Huel Black Edition17 meals£33.90£1.99£1.25

Protein Works prices from Protein Works' feed on 19 October 2026: PLATINUM and GOLD at the OnTap subscription price, the rest one-off. Diet Meal 360 meals counted from the Chocolate Silk serving size (60g PLATINUM, 70g GOLD, 65g BLACK). Huel on uk.huel.com and Myprotein on myprotein.com, 19 to 20 October. Bulk on bulk.com, 14 October. PER4M from WheyWise's Amazon UK price data, 19 October. n/a: we haven't verified the protein figure.

Subscriptions change the Huel numbers. Huel takes 10% off recurring orders, which puts Huel Powder at £1.59 a meal and Huel Black Edition at £1.79 a meal, or £1.12 per 25g of protein. On a like-for-like subscription, Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM at £1.20 a meal is about a quarter cheaper than Huel Powder. Code WW12 takes 12% off most Protein Works orders; we list live codes on the deals page. For every meal shake we track ranked by cost per 25g of protein with live prices, use the meal replacement comparison.

What's the best value high-protein meal replacement for men cutting body fat?

Huel Black Edition is the best value high-protein meal for a man cutting on a bigger calorie budget: 40g of protein and 1.6g of sugar in a 400 kcal meal, at £1.12 per 25g of protein on a Huel subscription or £1.25 bought one-off. The cheapest per gram of protein bought one-off is Protein Works Complete Meal 360 Gold, at £1.15 per 25g, but it gives 30g of protein with 9.0g of sugar. No shake takes fat off one area such as the belly: a calorie deficit takes it off everywhere, and these shakes make the deficit easier to keep.

Per servingServingCaloriesProteinFibreSugar
Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM60g216 kcal25g5.0g1.1g
Protein Works Diet Meal 360 GOLD70g245 kcal20gn/an/a
Protein Works Diet Meal 360 BLACK65g239 kcal16gn/an/a
Myprotein Protein Meal Replacement Blend51g208 kcal18g4.1g14g
Protein Works Complete Meal 360 Gold100g400 kcal30g7.8g9.0g
Huel Powder100g400 kcal30g8.0g1.2g
Huel Black Edition90g400 kcal40g8.4g1.6g
Bulk 1 Complete Food Shake100g400 kcal30g9.6g2.3g
PER4M Meal Replacement60gn/a25gn/an/a

Labels: Protein Works Chocolate Silk and Complete Meal labels on theproteinworks.com. Huel Powder Banana and Huel Black Edition Matcha Latte labels on uk.huel.com. Myprotein Strawberry label on myprotein.com. Bulk label on bulk.com. n/a means the figure was not on the label we checked or the brand page does not publish it.

If you are cutting on a smaller calorie budget, the 216 kcal Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM is the better fit, with 25g of protein at £1.20 per 25g on OnTap. Myprotein Protein Meal Replacement Blend is the outlier on sugar at 14g per serving.

Which affordable meal replacement meets the UK rules for weight loss?

Protein Works Diet Meal 360 BLACK is the cheapest shake we found that meets the UK weight-control rules on its label, at 98p a meal: 239 kcal and 16g of protein per serving, with 23 vitamins and minerals each at 30% or more of the NRV. We can't tell you which shake dietitians recommend, and we don't claim any endorsement, but the rules are the objective test. A meal replacement for weight control in Great Britain needs 200 to 250 kcal per meal, 25% to 50% of its energy from protein, no more than 30% from fat and at least 30% of the NRV for its vitamins and minerals, under retained Regulation (EU) No 432/2012, checked on legislation.gov.uk.

Shakekcal per mealEnergy from proteinIn the 200 to 250 kcal band?Per meal
Protein Works Diet Meal 360 BLACK23927%Yes98p
Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM21646%Yes£1.20 (OnTap)
Myprotein Protein Meal Replacement Blend20835%Yes£1.23
Huel Powder40030%No, a full meal£1.76

Energy from protein = grams of protein × 4 kcal ÷ kcal per meal, from each label. Prices as in the price table above.

The 400 kcal shakes, Huel Powder, Huel Black Edition, Bulk 1 Complete Food Shake and Protein Works Complete Meal 360, are a different product: a full meal, not a diet meal. That makes them a better fit for replacing a normal-sized lunch than for cutting calories. A total diet replacement, where shakes replace every meal, is a third category with its own rules: between 600 and 1,200 kcal and 75g to 105g of protein for the whole day, under Regulation (EU) 2017/1798. This guide does not cover total diet replacement, which is best done with professional support.

Should you use a cheap meal replacement or a cheap whey shake to lose weight?

Use a meal replacement if the shake is standing in for a meal, and a cheap whey if it is topping up protein between normal meals. A meal replacement is built to replace a meal, with carbohydrate, fibre and added vitamins and minerals: Protein Works Diet Meal 360 BLACK does that for 98p a meal. A whey shake gives protein and little else, but it is cheaper per gram of protein: Protein Works Whey Protein 360 Black costs 60p per 25g of protein on OnTap, and PhD Diet Whey, a diet whey sold for cutting, £1.19 per 25g on Amazon UK.

Per servingkcalProteinAdded vitamins and mineralsPer 25g of protein
Protein Works Diet Meal 360 BLACK (meal replacement)23916g23£1.54
PhD Diet Whey (diet whey)12320gNone£1.19
Protein Works Whey Protein 360 Black (whey)n/a59g per 100gNone60p (OnTap)

PhD Diet Whey Belgian Chocolate label on phd.com, 32g serving; price from WheyWise's Amazon UK data on 20 October 2026, 2kg at £58.93. Whey 360 Black Chocolate Silk label; 4.8kg at £68.49 on OnTap in Protein Works' feed on 19 October 2026. n/a: we haven't read a per-serving calorie figure.

Drinking a plain protein shake instead of lunch will cut calories, but it leaves out most of what a meal replacement is made to include, and 123 kcal falls well short of the 200 kcal floor for a meal replacement. For protein top-ups on a diet, see the best protein powder for weight loss UK guide. Huel also sells a straight protein powder rather than a meal, which we check in is Huel protein powder good.

A diet whey, not a meal replacement

Pros

  • 20g of protein in 123 kcal per 32g serving, with 0.9g of sugar (Belgian Chocolate label, phd.com)
  • £1.19 per 25g of protein in the 2kg bag at £58.93 on Amazon UK, WheyWise price data
  • 62g of protein per 100g, with green tea extract, CLA and acetyl L-carnitine added

Cons

  • No added vitamins or minerals, so it cannot stand in for a meal
  • 123 kcal per serving, below the 200 to 250 kcal band for a meal replacement
  • 1.7g of fibre per serving
Buy PhD Diet Whey Protein Powder →See the price on Amazon
●Nutrition per scoop · 19.8g protein in 32g▼

Protein makes up 62%

of this 32g scoop · 109 kcal total

19.8g
6.8g
Protein19.8g
Carbs3.8g
Fat1.6g
Other6.8g

Which diet shake actually keeps you full?

Pick the diet shake with the most protein per calorie: Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM gives 25g of protein in 216 kcal, the most protein of the diet meal shakes in this guide, and higher-protein meals leave people feeling fuller. A review of the evidence by Leidy et al., 2015 found a modest satiety effect from higher-protein meals, with greater perceived fullness, and pointed to at least about 25g to 30g of protein per meal. The same review did not find that higher-protein meals cut how much people ate at their next meal, so a shake helps with hunger but does not do the dieting for you.

Thickness matters too. Our founder bought and drank Protein Works Diet Meal 360 GOLD, the tier below PLATINUM, and found one serving kept him full through a meal he would otherwise have skipped, which he put down to how thick it is. He has not tried PLATINUM himself yet, so we will not describe its texture. Protein Works' own 2026 survey of 474 PLATINUM users, which is the brand's self-reported customer research rather than an independent trial, found 91.4% said it was the most effective weight management meal shake they had used, according to the Protein Works research page.

What's the best tasting meal replacement shake for your first calorie deficit?

Start with Protein Works Diet Meal 360 in Speculoos Biscuit Heaven: our founder scored it 8.5 out of 10 in the GOLD version, for its caramelised biscuit and vanilla taste and an aftertaste that clears within seconds. Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM is sold in the same Speculoos Biscuit Heaven flavour, alongside options such as Triple Chocolate Nirvana, Pistachio Ice Cream and Salted Caramel Bandit. A first diet is easier to stick to with a flavour you look forward to, so buy a small bag before committing to 4kg.

In Protein Works' own 2026 customer research, PLATINUM users gave it a 4.64-star average, with 71.1% giving it 5 stars. Treat that as the brand's self-reported survey of its own customers, not an independent taste test. Diet Meal 360 BLACK comes in five flavours, including Chocolate Silk and Strawberries 'n' Cream, so you can try the Diet Meal format for less before trading up. For the full hands-on notes on texture, mixing and digestion, read our Protein Works Diet Meal 360 GOLD review.

Is Huel better than Protein Works Diet Meal 360 for losing weight?

For losing weight, Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM fits the job better than Huel Powder: it gives 25g of protein in 216 kcal for £1.20 a meal on OnTap, against 30g of protein in 400 kcal for £1.59 a meal for Huel Powder on Huel's subscription. PLATINUM sits inside the 200 to 250 kcal band for weight-control meal replacements, and Huel Powder is a full meal. PLATINUM is also cheaper per gram of protein on a subscription, at £1.20 per 25g against £1.32.

Huel wins on fibre and diet. Huel Powder has 8.0g of fibre per meal against 5.0g in PLATINUM, and Huel says all its products are vegan, while the standard Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM is not (Protein Works sells a separate vegan version). Sugar is close, at 1.2g against 1.1g. Against Protein Works' own full meal, Complete Meal 360 Gold, Huel Powder has far less sugar, 1.2g against 9.0g per meal, though Complete Meal 360 Gold is cheaper at £1.37 a meal against £1.76 bought one-off. The full head-to-head is in Protein Works vs Huel.

What is the cheapest meal replacement shake that actually works for weight loss?

Protein Works Diet Meal 360 BLACK is the cheapest meal replacement that does the job, at 98p a meal in the 4kg bag at £59.99. “Works” here means two things: its label meets the GB composition rules for weight-control meal replacements, at 239 kcal per 65g serving with 23 added vitamins and minerals, and meal replacement programmes as a whole beat standard diets in the trials covered further down. The trade is protein: 16g per serving against 25g in PLATINUM, which makes BLACK £1.54 per 25g of protein against £1.20 for PLATINUM on OnTap.

Cheapest per meal

Pros

  • 98p a meal in the 4kg bag at £59.99, the lowest per meal in this guide
  • Five flavours at Protein Works, from Chocolate Silk to Strawberries 'n' Cream
  • 239 kcal per 65g serving with 23 added vitamins and minerals (Chocolate Silk label)

Cons

  • 16g of protein per serving, against 25g in Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM
  • £1.54 per 25g of protein, more than PLATINUM's £1.20 on OnTap
Buy Diet Meal 360 Black →Price at Protein Works
Exclusive WheyWise Code
Get 12% off your order
Search on Amazon ↗
or compare all UK prices →
●Nutrition per scoop · 15.6g protein in 65g▼

Protein makes up 24%

of this 65g scoop · 234 kcal total

15.6g
34.5g
11.2g
Protein15.6g
Carbs34.5g
Fat3.7g
Other11.2g

Myprotein Protein Meal Replacement Blend is the next cheapest light meal, at £1.23 a meal for £36.99 in the 1.53kg bag on myprotein.com, but it carries 14g of sugar per serving and costs £1.71 per 25g of protein. PER4M Meal Replacement costs £1.43 a meal for its 1.8kg bag on Amazon UK.

Cheap light meal, more sugar

Pros

  • £1.23 a meal in the 1.53kg bag at £36.99, checked on myprotein.com
  • 208 kcal and 18g of protein per 51g serving (Strawberry label), inside the 200 to 250 kcal band
  • 4.1g of fibre per serving, plus added vitamins and minerals

Cons

  • 14g of sugar per serving, the most of any shake in this guide
  • £1.71 per 25g of protein, against £1.20 for Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM on OnTap
or compare all UK prices →
●Nutrition per scoop · 17.9g protein in 51g▼

Protein makes up 35%

of this 51g scoop · 198 kcal total

17.9g
16.8g
9.7g
Protein17.9g
Carbs16.8g
Fat6.6g
Other9.7g

What's the best affordable meal replacement for women replacing breakfast?

Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM is the best affordable breakfast replacement, at £1.20 a meal on OnTap: 216 kcal and 25g of protein is a measured breakfast that leaves room in a smaller daily calorie budget. The NHS puts the average woman's needs at around 2,000 kcal a day against 2,500 for men, so a 216 kcal breakfast fits a deficit more easily than a 400 kcal full-meal shake. If budget comes first, Diet Meal 360 BLACK is 98p a meal at 239 kcal.

Breakfast shakekcalProteinPer meal
Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM21625g£1.20 (OnTap)
Protein Works Diet Meal 360 BLACK23916g98p
Huel Powder40030g£1.76

Nothing in these shakes is formulated for women in particular; the difference is the calorie budget. If you train hard or want more protein in the morning, see our best protein powder for women guide.

What is the best vegan meal replacement shake that keeps you full until lunch?

Bulk 1 Complete Food Shake is the vegan meal to keep you full until lunch: 400 kcal with 30g of protein and 9.6g of fibre per 100g meal, the most fibre of any shake here, at £1.67 a meal in the 3kg bag. Protein Works Vegan Complete Meal 360 Gold is 6p a meal cheaper at £1.61 in the 4kg bag, with 0.5g of sugar and 9.4g of fibre per 400 kcal meal. For more protein, Huel Black Edition is vegan too, with 40g of protein per 400 kcal meal for £1.99 one-off or £1.79 on subscription.

Vegan meal (400 kcal)ProteinFibreSugarPer meal
Bulk 1 Complete Food Shake30g9.6g2.3g£1.67
Protein Works Vegan Complete Meal 360 Goldn/a9.4g0.5g£1.61
Huel Black Edition40g8.4g1.6g£1.99
Huel Powder30g8.0g1.2g£1.76

All four are full 400 kcal meals. Protein Works also sells a Vegan Diet Meal 360 in GOLD and PLATINUM for calorie-controlled diets, but we have not verified their labels, so they are not in our tables. For plant protein powders rather than meals, see the best vegan protein powder UK guide.

Is it safe to replace two meals a day with a shake?

For most healthy adults, replacing two meals a day with a properly formulated meal replacement is an established approach: it is exactly what the authorised GB claim describes, which says substituting two of the main daily meals of an energy-restricted diet with meal replacements contributes to weight loss. The claim only applies to shakes that meet the composition rules, so check for 200 to 250 kcal and added vitamins and minerals. Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM, with 216 kcal and 24 vitamins and minerals at 30% or more of the NRV, meets that spec on its label.

The trial evidence is reassuring when one normal meal stays in the day. A pooled analysis of six randomised trials of partial meal replacement, using one or two fortified shakes plus regular food, found no reported adverse events attributable to either the shakes or the comparison diet, and fewer dropouts on the shakes at one year (Heymsfield et al., 2003). Replacing every meal is different: the NHS runs it as a supported programme of 800 to 900 kcal a day for 12 weeks for people with type 2 diabetes, not as a do-it-yourself diet.

Speak to your GP first if you have a medical condition, are pregnant or have a history of disordered eating. If you take medication for diabetes or blood pressure, that matters too: in the DiRECT trial, those drugs were withdrawn as part of the GP-led programme at the start of the diet.

Do meal replacement shakes work, or will you put the weight back on?

Meal replacement shakes do work for weight loss, and the best evidence says by more than a standard diet. A systematic review of 23 randomised trials with 7,884 adults found programmes using meal replacements led to 1.44kg more weight loss at one year than other diets, rising to 6.13kg more when they came with enhanced support (Astbury et al., 2019). Three of that review's authors declared a research grant from a meal replacement company, Cambridge Weight Plan UK, which is worth knowing.

Some weight usually comes back, and support makes the difference. In the UK DiRECT trial, people on a total diet replacement of 825 to 853 kcal a day lost an average of 10.0kg at 12 months, against 1.0kg in the control group (Lean et al., 2018). At two years the gap had narrowed to 5.4kg, and the share keeping off at least 15kg fell from 24% to 11% (Lean et al., 2019). The plan for keeping it off matters as much as the shake: the authorised GB claim for a single meal replacement a day is about maintaining weight after weight loss, which is how most people step down from two shakes.

Are meal replacement shakes worth it, or should you just eat less?

A meal replacement shake is worth it if a fixed, measured meal makes eating less easier for you, and Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM costs £1.20 a meal on OnTap. The shake does not burn fat on its own: it works because each meal has a known 216 kcal and 25g of protein, so the calorie cut is built in. If you already eat less without effort, normal food gives you the same result for free.

Who it suits: anyone cutting calories who skips meals or grabs whatever is nearest at lunch, shift workers without a proper meal break, and anyone who wants a measured breakfast with protein in it. Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM is the pick for that, with Diet Meal 360 BLACK at 98p a meal if price comes first.

Who should skip it: anyone under medical care for diabetes, blood pressure or an eating disorder without speaking to their GP first, and anyone who wants a full 400 kcal meal rather than a diet meal, who should look at Bulk 1 Complete Food Shake or Huel instead. For live prices across every meal shake we track, use the meal replacement comparison, and for the rest of the range, see our Protein Works range guide.

Frequently asked questions

Which meal replacement shake is best for a healthy breakfast on the go?

Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM. A 60g serving gives 25g of protein in 216 kcal with 24 added vitamins and minerals, and it costs £1.20 a meal on Protein Works' OnTap subscription price. Replacing one main meal a day is exactly how the authorised GB claim is written: substituting one of the main daily meals of an energy-restricted diet with a meal replacement contributes to the maintenance of weight after weight loss.

What is the cheapest nutritionally complete meal replacement shake in the UK?

Protein Works Diet Meal 360 BLACK, at 98p a meal in the 4kg bag at £59.99. Its label gives 239 kcal and 16g of protein per 65g serving, with 23 vitamins and minerals each at 30% or more of the NRV. If you want a full 400 kcal meal rather than a diet meal, Protein Works Complete Meal 360 Gold costs £1.37 a meal in the 4kg bag at £54.99.

What meal replacement shake do dietitians recommend for busy people who skip meals?

We can't speak for dietitians, and we won't claim an endorsement for any brand. What we can give you is the UK standard a weight-control meal replacement has to meet: 200 to 250 kcal, 25% to 50% of its energy from protein, no more than 30% from fat, and at least 30% of the NRV for its vitamins and minerals. Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM meets it on its label, with 216 kcal and 25g of protein, at £1.20 a meal on OnTap.

What is the best meal replacement shake under £2 a meal?

Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM, at £1.20 a meal on Protein Works' OnTap subscription price. Every shake in this guide comes in under £2 a meal: Huel Black Edition is the dearest at £1.99 bought one-off, and Diet Meal 360 BLACK the cheapest at 98p.

Which meal replacement shake is best for shift workers?

Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM, because a measured 216 kcal meal with 25g of protein travels in a shaker and needs only water, which is what a night shift with no proper break allows, and it costs £1.20 a meal on OnTap. Keep one normal meal in the day: the authorised GB claim for weight loss covers replacing up to two of the main daily meals, not all of them.

Is a meal replacement powder or a protein shake with oats better value for weight loss?

A whey shake with oats is cheaper per gram of protein: Protein Works Whey Protein 360 Black costs 60p per 25g of protein on OnTap, half the £1.20 of Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM. The meal replacement gives you a measured 216 kcal with 24 added vitamins and minerals and nothing to weigh, while the DIY version needs you to weigh the oats every time and adds no vitamins. Pick the DIY shake if you'll measure it; pick the meal replacement if convenience is what keeps you on the diet.

What budget meal replacement shake is good for losing a stone?

Protein Works Diet Meal 360 BLACK, at 98p a meal bought one-off. It sits inside the 200 to 250 kcal band for weight-control meal replacements at 239 kcal a serving. How long a stone takes depends on the size of your calorie deficit, not on the shake, so we don't give a timeline.

What is the cheapest vegan meal replacement shake for weight loss?

The cheapest vegan meal we verified is Protein Works Vegan Complete Meal 360 Gold, at £1.61 a meal in the 4kg bag, with 0.5g of sugar and 9.4g of fibre per meal. It is a full 400 kcal meal, not a diet meal, so use it to replace a normal-sized lunch. Protein Works also sells a Vegan Diet Meal 360 for calorie-controlled diets, but we haven't verified its label.

Which meal replacement gives the most protein per pound if I replace two meals a day?

Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM, at £1.20 per 25g of protein on OnTap. Replacing two meals a day only fits the authorised weight-loss claim with shakes in the 200 to 250 kcal band, and among those PLATINUM has the most protein per serving, 25g, and the lowest cost per gram: Diet Meal 360 BLACK is £1.54 per 25g of protein and Myprotein Protein Meal Replacement Blend £1.71.

Is a meal replacement shake or a protein bar better value when working long shifts?

The shake. Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM gives 25g of protein and 24 added vitamins and minerals in 216 kcal for £1.20 a meal on OnTap, while the Myprotein Layered Bar gives 20g of protein in 212 kcal for £1.83 a bar in a box of 12. A bar is a snack; a meal replacement is built to stand in for the meal.

How many meal replacement shakes a day should I have to lose weight?

Two at most, alongside one normal meal. The authorised GB claim is that substituting two of the main daily meals of an energy-restricted diet with meal replacements contributes to weight loss, and it only applies to shakes with 200 to 250 kcal per meal that meet the other composition rules. Replacing every meal is a total diet replacement, a different product with its own rules.

Is Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM a full meal replacement?

It is a light meal replacement built for calorie-controlled diets rather than a full 400 kcal meal. One 60g serving of Protein Works Diet Meal 360 PLATINUM gives 216 kcal, 25g of protein, 5.0g of fibre and 1.1g of sugar on the Chocolate Silk label, plus 24 vitamins and minerals each at 30% or more of the NRV.

Is PhD Diet Whey a meal replacement?

No. PhD Diet Whey is a diet whey: one 32g serving gives 20g of protein in 123 kcal, with 1.7g of fibre and no added vitamins or minerals, on the Belgian Chocolate label checked on phd.com. That is too few calories and nutrients to replace a meal, so use it to top up protein between meals instead.

Find your cheapest protein

796 products compared from 182 brands

Sorted by best value per 25g of protein.

Compare all products