Back to Blog
Explainer

What Are BCAAs For, and Do You Need Them?

You probably do not need BCAAs: if you already eat enough protein they add little, because whey protein already contains them, along with the other amino acids they need to work. A scoop of Myprotein Impact Whey gives 5g of BCAAs plus 22g of protein, for £1.00 in the 3.6kg bag.

KE

Kevin, founder of WheyWise

3 October 2026Updated 4 October 20263 min read

Quick answer

BCAAs are leucine, isoleucine and valine, three of the nine essential amino acids, and if you already eat enough protein they add little, because protein already contains them. Myprotein says a 30g scoop of its Impact Whey gives 5g of naturally occurring BCAAs plus 22g of protein, against 4g of BCAAs in a 5g serving of its Impact BCAA 2:1:1. Put the money towards whey instead: Protein Works Whey Protein 360 Black gives you all nine essential amino acids for about 65p per 25g of protein in the 4.8kg bag.

BCAA drinks are sold as a muscle-building extra, and they are one of the easiest supplements to drop. The short version: whey protein already contains them, along with the other amino acids they need to work. Labels and prices below were checked on myprotein.com.

For how much you need and how to split it across the day, see our guide to how much protein powder to take per day.

What are BCAAs?

BCAAs, or branched-chain amino acids, are leucine, isoleucine and valine, three of the nine essential amino acids that the British Nutrition Foundation lists as the ones your diet must supply. Most BCAA powders use a 2:1:1 ratio: Myprotein Impact BCAA 2:1:1 gives 2g of leucine, 1g of isoleucine and 1g of valine per 5g serving, and Myprotein suggests taking it before, during or after exercise.

Do BCAAs build muscle on their own?

Only weakly. Wolfe's 2017 review found no human study that had measured muscle protein synthesis after drinking BCAAs alone, and concluded that the claim they produce an anabolic response is unwarranted, because the other six essential amino acids needed to build new muscle protein would have to come from breaking down existing muscle (Wolfe, 2017).

A trial published the same year did test it. Ten trained men drinking 5.6g of BCAAs after leg training had 22% higher myofibrillar protein synthesis than with a placebo, but the authors put that response about 50% below what a dose of whey with similar BCAAs produced in their earlier work (Jackman et al., 2017). BCAAs do something; whole protein does more.

Are BCAAs better value than whey protein?

No: a scoop of Myprotein Impact Whey gives more BCAAs than a serving of Myprotein Impact BCAA 2:1:1, plus 22g of protein and all nine essential amino acids, for £1.00 a scoop in the 3.6kg bag against 33p a serving from the 500g BCAA tub at £32.99. The BCAA drink is cheaper per serving, but it is three amino acids in water.

Per servingMyprotein Impact BCAA 2:1:1 (5g)Myprotein Impact Whey (30g)
BCAAs4g5g
Leucine2gNot listed
Essential amino acids3 of 9All 9
ProteinNot listed22g
Price per serving33p (500g, £32.99)£1.00 (3.6kg, £119.99)

Labels and prices on myprotein.com. Impact BCAA is the Unflavoured tub; Impact Whey is Vanilla. The 5g BCAA figure for Impact Whey is Myprotein's own claim per 30g scoop.

Whey instead of a BCAA drink, for less per gram

Pros

  • All nine essential amino acids, BCAAs included, in every scoop
  • About 65p per 25g of protein in the 4.8kg bag at the one-off price
  • 18g of protein per 30g scoop

Cons

  • 59g of protein per 100g, less dense than an isolate
  • Protein Works does not publish a BCAA figure per scoop
Buy Whey Protein 360 Black →Price at Protein Works
Exclusive WheyWise Code
Get 12% off your order
Search on Amazon ↗
or compare all UK prices →
●Nutrition per scoop · 17.7g protein in 30g▼

Protein makes up 59%

of this 30g scoop · 109 kcal total

17.7g
7.5g
Protein17.7g
Carbs7.5g
Fat1g
Other3.8g

More BCAAs per serving than a BCAA scoop

Pros

  • 5g of naturally occurring BCAAs per 30g scoop, according to Myprotein
  • 22g of protein and all nine essential amino acids in the same scoop
  • £1.00 a scoop in the 3.6kg Vanilla bag

Cons

  • £1.00 a serving against 33p for Myprotein Impact BCAA 2:1:1
  • The flavoured versions use sucralose
or compare all UK prices →
●Nutrition per scoop · 21.6g protein in 30g▼

Protein makes up 72%

of this 30g scoop · 113 kcal total

21.6g
Protein21.6g
Carbs2.7g
Fat1.8g
Other3.9g

If you hit your daily protein goal, skip BCAAs. If you want an amino drink anyway, an EAA product supplies all nine essential amino acids, which is the gap Wolfe identified; we compare both by cost per serving on the BCAA and EAA comparison.

Frequently asked questions

Are BCAAs worth it if I take whey protein?

Usually not. Myprotein says one 30g scoop of Impact Whey provides 5g of naturally occurring BCAAs, more than the 4g in a 5g serving of Myprotein Impact BCAA 2:1:1. A 2017 review concluded that the claim BCAAs alone produce an anabolic response in humans is unwarranted.

What is the difference between BCAAs and EAAs?

BCAAs are three amino acids: leucine, isoleucine and valine. EAAs are all nine essential amino acids, adding histidine, lysine, methionine, phenylalanine, threonine and tryptophan. Building muscle protein needs all nine, which is why a 2017 review argued BCAAs alone can't drive much new muscle.

Do BCAAs help muscle growth at all?

A little. In a 2017 trial, 5.6g of BCAAs after training raised myofibrillar protein synthesis 22% above a placebo, a response the authors put at about 50% less than whey with a similar amount of BCAAs. Whole protein does the job better.

Find your cheapest protein

796 products compared from 182 brands

Sorted by best value per 25g of protein.

Compare all products