Protein · head-to-head

Applied Nutrition Critical Whey vs Bulk Pure Whey.

Our independent head-to-head review of Applied Nutrition Critical Whey and Bulk Pure Whey Protein, scored on value, protein density, macros and ingredient quality so you don't have to guess which to buy.

Applied Nutrition

Critical Whey

77p / 25g protein

72g protein / 100g

Applied Nutrition Critical Whey

Bulk

Pure Whey Protein

70p / 25g protein

71g protein / 100g

Bulk Pure Whey Protein

What a scoop actually contains

Applied Nutrition Critical Whey

128 kcal · 33 g scoop

Protein is 72% of the scoop

Protein
23.8 g
(72%)
Carbs
3.8 g
(12%)
Fat
2.0 g
(6%)
Other
3.4 g
(10%)

Bulk Pure Whey Protein

120 kcal · 32 g scoop

Protein is 71% of the scoop

Protein
22.7 g
(71%)
Carbs
4.8 g
(15%)
Fat
1.1 g
(4%)
Other
3.4 g
(11%)

WheyWise verdict

Bulk Pure Whey Protein wins for most buyers.

Runner-upPrefer Applied Nutrition Critical Whey? It is the second pick here, not a bad one - and Amazon stocks it.

  • 71g protein per 100g at consistently low prices
  • Bigger bag sizes (up to 5kg) for maximum savings
  • Transparent pricing - no inflated RRPs

How the numbers stack up against the price

Applied Nutrition Critical Whey and Bulk Pure Whey Protein represent two different approaches to budget protein in the UK. Applied Nutrition Critical Whey is the Amazon bestseller - available with Prime next-day delivery, consistent pricing with no discount codes to hunt for, and a 4-protein blend delivering 72g of protein per 100g. Bulk Pure Whey Protein is the direct-to-consumer champion - ordered from bulk.com with 71g of protein per 100g and a reputation for being one of the cheapest whey concentrates available when bought in larger sizes.

Cost per 25g protein

Lower is better

Applied Nutrition Critical Whey77p
Bulk Pure Whey Protein70pWins

Protein per scoop

Higher is better

Applied Nutrition Critical Whey23.8 gWins
Bulk Pure Whey Protein22.7 g

Carbs per scoop

Lower is better

Applied Nutrition Critical Whey3.8 gWins
Bulk Pure Whey Protein4.8 g

Fat per scoop

Lower is better

Applied Nutrition Critical Whey2.0 g
Bulk Pure Whey Protein1.1 gWins

Protein density

Higher is better

Applied Nutrition Critical Whey72 g/100gWins
Bulk Pure Whey Protein71 g/100g

WheyWise score

Out of 5

Applied Nutrition Critical Whey3.4Wins
Bulk Pure Whey Protein3.2

Bulk Pure Whey Protein edges ahead on pure value.

When you buy a 2.5kg or 5kg bag, the per-100g price is consistently lower than Applied Nutrition Critical Whey, and the protein content is virtually identical. However, Applied Nutrition Critical Whey has a genuine convenience advantage that is worth real money to some buyers - Amazon Prime delivery, easy returns, Subscribe & Save discounts, and no waiting for sales. If you value your time and want hassle-free buying, Applied Nutrition Critical Whey is worth the small premium. If you want the absolute cheapest gram of protein in the UK, Bulk Pure Whey Protein delivers.

Where each one wins

Takes protein per scoop, carbs per scoop, protein density and the WheyWise score.

Takes cost per 25g protein and fat per scoop.

Neither of these quite right?

Answer five questions about your goal, budget and diet, and the Protein Finder ranks the whole range against them, with the reason each pick won.

Open the Protein Finder